Written by Emily Harstone August 18th, 2016

The Novice Mistake Most Writers Make When Submitting to Publishers

There is one mistake that most authors make when submitting their work to literary journals and magazines for the first time. It is a mistake I made the first time I submitted. It is a mistake that most of the serious authors I know made.

What is that mistake? Is it a terrible cover letter? Awful poetry?

No. In fact, it is far simpler than that. The mistake that most authors make when they first start out is that they submit to a very prestigious literary journal or magazine. My use of singular here is very deliberate.

Most authors start out by submitting to only one publication. That literary journal or magazine is usually extremely prestigious and very competitive. The New Yorker is a common first magazine to submit to. Tin House or Rattle are common first literary journals to submit to. Even if you are a writer not familiar with literary journals or magazines, you probably know these names.

These journals accept far less than 1% of what is submitted to them. That does not mean that one shouldn’t submit to them. There is nothing to lose and much to gain by submitting to a journal or magazine that is prestigious or well known.

The problem is this, the first time submitter usually only submits to one well known journal. Then they wait for a response. Some journals respond quickly, but many of the established ones take six months to a year.

These places all accept simultaneous submissions, so authors could submit the same work elsewhere during this time, or those same authors could submit other work elsewhere to increase their chances of having a piece accepted. They should probably submit other work to a lesser known journal or two (or thirty, if they are really serious).

Most don’t. I didn’t when I first started out. What I did was wait almost a year for The New Yorker to reject the three poems that I submitted to them. That was a year’s worth of potential publication that I lost. For no good reason. I could have been submitting elsewhere at the same time.

Don’t take this as discouragement against submitting to The New Yorker. Take this as encouragement to submit to The New Yorker, Rattle, Tin House, and at least five other lesser known literary journals.

Don’t make the same mistake I did. Start submitting today, but don’t stop with one journal. Keep going. Submit often. That is the best advice I can give any writer who is new to the world of publishing.


We Send You Publishers Seeking Submissions.

Sign up for our free e-magazine and we will send you reviews of publishers seeking short stories, poetry, essays, and books.

Subscribe now and we'll send you a free copy of our book Submit, Publish, Repeat