Written by February 7th, 2018

What Rejection Letters Really Mean

by Wendy S. Delmater

Oh no. Your literary creation—poem, article, novel, or story—has been rejected. What do you do now?

One of the first questions you should ask is, was this a Form Rejection or a Personalized Rejection? When you use The Grinder (by Diabolical Plots) to keep track of your submissions, it even gives you those options on a drop down menu. And there a shades of rejection letters, something called “tiered rejections.” Every publication has different rejection letters, too. One thing you can do is to take a look at the rejection wiki to see if the market you submitted it to has sample rejection letters.

If it’s a form rejection letter, try not to read too much into it. Editors are busy, and they are desperately trying to pare down a veritable mountain of submissions into a manageable pile. They rarely have time for any comments in a rejection. And sometimes they are so inundated, or so behind, that they do mass rejections without even reading it. So, by sending a form rejection they did not say you were a bad writer, they just said not this story, not this time. And the reason may have nothing to do with what you wrote; it could be that someone else also sent a story they just bought which is about talking asparagus or alien lichens or giant hummingbirds from hell. And they cannot publish two stories about the same subject.

The Personalized Rejection is actually brag-worthy. It means they liked it enough to encourage you. If the editor has any suggestions for improvement in that rejection letter, consider using these suggestions in a rewrite. Unless the editor totally did not get what you were doing and wants to materially change the story until it’s unrecognizable, which happens, it’s worth a try. They are giving you free advice and sometimes editors charge for such advice, so it’s a gift when they offer help. Use it wisely, but do not assume they want a rewrite sent right back. If they want a rewrite they will say so.

Here is a link to an example of a tiered rejection system. This publisher has rejections they call the Very Good, The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly rejections. The Very Good rejections have comments: they’re personalized. The Good, the Bad and the Ugly rejections have different wording, but no comments.

Try to avoid sending a rejected story to a market that has already seen it. Keep track of where you’ve sent things so you do not make that mistake.

And then, write the next thing while you’re waiting. Writing is like anything else: the more you do it, the better you get at it. And remember this old saying, “You’re not a real writer until you can wallpaper a room with rejection letters.” In this digital age, you’d have to print them out to make that wallpaper, which I don’t suggest. But you get the idea. Just keep kicking the submissions back into play, and keep track of where you sent them. Rejections are a badge of honor in a way, because sending your work back out means you’re persevering.

And, for a writer, perseverance is equally valuable as your ability to write well.


Wendy S. Delmater is the author of Confessions of a Female Safety Engineer, and the Better Dating Through Engineering series. She has been editor of the Hugo-nominated magazine, Abyss & Apex, since 2006. She is also the editor of The Best of Abyss & Apex, Volumes 1 and 2. Wendy’s recent publication credits include short stories and poetry in The Singularity magazine, Gathering Storm Magazine, Little Blue Marble, Star*Line, Illumen, and Silver Blade Magazine. You can visit her Amazon Author page, which contains her blog, or follow her on Twitter where she’s known as @safewrite.

 

We Send You Publishers Seeking Submissions.

Sign up for our free e-magazine and we will send you reviews of publishers seeking short stories, poetry, essays, and books.

Subscribe now and we'll send you a free copy of our book Submit, Publish, Repeat

Inkubator Books

Inkubator Books

This Dublin, Ireland-based press focuses on publishing crime fiction, mystery, and thrillers. They do not publish work outside of this genre, and they do not publish work outside of Amazon. Most of the work they publish do very well on Amazon through Kindle Unlimited. The books they publish are not just available digitally, they also…

Watertower Hill Publishing

Watertower Hill Publishing

A small press founded in 2020 by Joshua L. Daughrity, who publishes his work under the pen name Joshua Loyd Fox. It started out as a self-publishing operation, but expanded from there into anthologies. Watertower Hill held their first open reading period for manuscripts in 2023. They are transparent about how many authors they signed…

Subtle Body Press

Subtle Body Press

Subtle Body Press is a small press that publishes a schizo-philosophical / countercultural journal series called Seven Story Hotel and a short fiction focused literary journal called Body Shots, both of which are currently open to submissions. They are also seeking a novella-length work of fiction or creative nonfiction to publish this year.  This is…

Windhorse Publications

Windhorse Publications

Windhorse Publications is an independent publisher of English-language nonfiction books on Buddhism, meditation and mindfulness. The work they publish is for Buddhist practitioners of all stages as well as for non-Buddhist readership. They also say, “We are also interested in books exploring new directions in Buddhist scholarship.” Like most faith-based publications, they are only interested…